Catch all the Top NFL Prop Picks & Best Prop Bets right here, every week, on Big Guy Fantasy Sports!
Every week, Colby Conway and Bob Lung use the Forecaster Consistency Tool to help you win your Fantasy Football Prop Bets! Follow them @colbyconway and @bob_lung. If you are looking for some weekly NFL player props, you’ve come to the right place! There are ample player props out there, but Bob Lung and Colby Conway provide their favorite player props to target for this week’s action across the National Football League.
The consistency concept can be applied to player props, just like it has for daily fantasy sports and seasonal fantasy football, so find those consistent players to give yourself the best chance of winning some money betting on player props.
NFL Week 2 – Prop Picks – 9/20/26 – Prop It Like It’s Hot!
Week 2 – NFL Prop Picks
Bijan Robinson OVER 82.5 Rushing Yards (-111)
Against the Panthers last season, Robinson rumbled for 72 yards and 104 yards in those two games, and he opened the 2026 campaign by posting 83 yards against the Steelers. The Panthers were absolutely decimated by the Bears’ rushing attack in Week 1, allowing eight yards per carry and four rushing touchdowns combined to D’Andre Swift and Kyle Monangai. I expect a heavy dosage of Robinson on Sunday, as Atlanta looks to rely on the ground game to keep this game within reach.
Xavier Hutchinson OVER 26.5 Receiving Yards (-109)
Nico Collins didn’t play in three games last season, and across those three games, Hutchinson had the second-highest snap share and route participation amongst the Houston pass-catchers, trailing only Jayden Higgins, who also won’t be playing in this game. Across those three games, Hutchinson posted a 22.9% target share and 65 yards per game, per FantasyPoints Data. Houston will need to score to keep up with Cincinnati, especially if Houston’s defense underwhelms again this week, and Hutchinson will be relied upon in the passing attack.
More Big Guy NFL Content
Malik Willis OVER 0.5 Interceptions (-128)
In Week 1, the 49ers forced Matthew Stafford into a 16% turnover-worthy play rate, per FantasyPoints Data, and in 2025, Stafford had only one game with a turnover-worthy play rate above 10% (10.5% in Week 17). Willis’ turnover-worthy play rate (3.7%) was above the league average (3.2%), and with the Dolphins playing from behind in this one, Willis is going to have to push the envelope a bit to make things happen. With multiple rookie receivers, a miscommunication or mental error is possible, and the 49ers have the talent to capitalize.
Kaelon Black OVER 9.5 Rushing Attempts (-107 DraftKings) and 41.5 Rushing Yards (-112)
If the 49ers are trying to keep Christian McCaffrey fresh by giving Kaelon Black 14 rushes for 65 yards against the Rams, then getting over 9.5 rushes for 41.5 yards seems quite easy, right? The Dolphins gave up 144 rushing yards to the Raiders this past week. We believe that the 49ers will jump out to a big lead and let CMC rest easy on the sidelines. Take the OVER for both.
David Montgomery – OVER 11.5 Receiving Yards (-113 DraftKings)
Montgomery ended last week with three catches for 19 yards against the Bills in a fairly high-scoring game. We expect the same this week against the Bengals. Many folks think Woody Marks is the receiving back for this team. But in last week’s game, he only had one catch. Monty will continue to be the bell cow back for this team.
Cam Ward – OVER 0.5 Interceptions (-121 DraftKings)
The Eagles’ defense is one of the league’s best. That was evident this past weekend versus Jayden Daniels and the Commanders offense. They shut down Daniels by holding him UNDER 200 yards in total offense. Cam Ward is nowhere near the talent of Jayden Daniels and looked lost versus the Raiders. This game could get out of hand really quickly, and Ward will try to salvage something, but he’s bound to throw a pick or two in this game. The -121 vig tells you that even Vegas doesn’t like this line.
You can find & follow @colbyconway and @bob_lung on the X! And thank you for joining us for our Week 2 NFL Prop Picks and Best Bets!
