NFL Week 5 Game of Fantasy Points: Is Dowdle King this week?

We’ve got a great Monday Night NFL Week 5 game in Jacksonville this week. 3.5 points favor the Chiefs despite being on the road. We lost the last remaining undefeated teams this week (the Eagles and Bills), which emphasizes the importance of each week. Is tonight’s game destined to be a consistent fantasy football success?

As per usual, now I am back to review the highest projected and most consistent fantasy football matchups for NFL Week 5. I’ll also go over tonight’s Monday Night Football matchup between the Chiefs and Jaguars from a consistent fantasy viewpoint. Can anyone top Rico Dowdle and his 32.4 fantasy points so far this week?

Which games profiled as the best for fantasy consistency purposes, and which games actually delivered? Moreso, let’s dig in and see how the Consistency Trend Report could lead you to fantasy gold!

Also, be sure to sign up today to get access to our articles and grab a paid subscription to get all of the amazing consistency tools available at BGFS! Generally, these tools are your league winners!

*All points are full PPR and based on points scored through 10/5/25.

Fantasy Football Game of the Week – 10/6/2025 Fantasy Football: Consistency

Embed from Getty Images

Highest Projected Clutch Games Expected Week 5 (with results):

• Lions (-9.5) at Bengals, 9 Expected Clutch Players
  • Actual Score and Clutch Players,
    • 37-24, Lions, 10 Clutch Players
      • DET (5): Jared Goff, Jahmyr Gibbs, David Montgomery, Amon-Ra St. Brown, Sam LaPorta
      • CIN (5): Jake Browning, Chase Brown, Ja’Marr Chase, Andrei Iosivas, Tee Higgins
• Raiders at Colts (-7.5), 9 Expected Clutch Players
  • Actual Score and Clutch Players,
    • 40-6, Colts, 6 Clutch Players
      • LV (2): Ashton Jeanty, Tre Tucker
      • IND (4): Jonathan Taylor, Michael Pittman, Josh Downs, Tyler Warren
• Buccaneers at Seahawks (-3.5), 8 Expected Clutch Players
  • Actual Score and Clutch Players,
    • 38-35, Buccaneers, 13 Clutch Players
      • TB (6): Baker Mayfield, Rachaad White, Emeka Egbuka, Sterling Shepard, Tez Johnson, Cade Otton
      • SEA (7): Sam Darnold, Zach Charbonnet, Kenneth Walker III, Jaxon Smith-Njigba, Tory Horton, Cooper Kupp, A.J. Barner
• Cowboys at Jets (-1.5), 7 Expected Clutch Players
  • Actual Score and Clutch Players,
    • 37-22, Cowboys, 9 Clutch Players
      • DAL (5): Dak Prescott, Javonte Williams, Ryan Flournoy, George Pickens, Jake Ferguson
      • NYJ (4): Justin Fields, Breece Hall, Garrett Wilson, Mason Taylor

More Big Guy Fantasy Football Wide Receiver Age Cliff.

• NFL Fantasy Week 5 Start/Sits Advice & Football Strategy
• NFL Week 5 Prop Picks And Best Prop Bet Predictions
• Top NFL Week 5 DFS Picks
• NFL Fantasy Football Week 5: Under the Radar with Consistency!

Embed from Getty Images

Notes from the Highest Projected Games

We had some great NFL Week 5 games, and only one of our highest projected let us down; that game was the Las Vegas Raiders versus the Indianapolis Colts. As a matter of fact, this game got out of hand early, as the Colts cruised to a 40-6 win. Our projections for that game were hurt by several injured players missing the game, including both Brock Bowers and Michael Mayer.

Featured the QB2 (Darnold), QB3 (Prescott), RB2 (Taylor), WR1 (Egbuka), WR2 (Chase), WR3 (Smith-Njigba), TE1 (Barner), and TE2 (Ferguson)

Despite that blowout, the four games projected for the highest consistency featured the three highest-scoring games this week, and even the blowout was 6th. Each of the other three games scored a combined 59 or more points.

Embed from Getty Images

NFL Week 5 Monday Night Football, Chiefs (-3.5) at Jaguars

Tonight for Monday Night Football, we’ve got the Kansas City Chiefs (2-2) visiting the Jacksonville Jaguars (3-1). Both teams have high expectations, and it should be a competitive contest (45.5 O/U); the Chiefs are only favored by 3.5.  The Chiefs lead the all-time series 10-6, including one postseason game between these two franchises.

The game is projected to have 6 Clutch performers. Patrick Mahomes should have his way with the Jaguars’ defense, so I anticipate he’ll lead the game in fantasy points. Additionally, he’s QB3 on the year, averaging 22.4 points per game. On the other side of the game, I see Travis Etienne (RB17) being heavily involved in the passing game and pacing the Jaguars in fantasy points. Should be a fun one to watch, but this game could be boring for the “Fantasy Game of Points”. I like the Chiefs more tonight, final score: 27-23, Chiefs.

More Big Guy Fantasy Football

• Fantasy Football QB Drafting: Early or Late, your QB needs this!
• Fantasy Football Risers: ADP Analysis For Your Draft
• Draft Targets: Fantasy Football ADP Winners
• Fantasy Football Tight Ends: Tiered Rankings and Draft Strategy

Additionally, the key to these articles is to realize that the consistency tools available here at BigGuyFantasySports can give you that competitive edge! I utilize our tools to project the best fantasy scoring matchups using four separate consistency reports to find which games stand out. If you’re around, I’ll be on X tonight, @JKeasy, hit me up and we can chat! Also, be sure to check out those consistency tools here on the site (articles are free, and the tools are a great deal). Still need more consistency? If so, click the banner above to buy the Consistency Guide by Bob Lung!

Got Your Big Guy Football Consistency Report Yet? Fantasy Consistency