When drafting for dynasty leagues, fantasy football quarterbacks outside the elite top five often define your long-term success. While stars like Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, and Jalen Hurts come with high price tags, value and upside often exist in the next tier. These QB1B options—those ranked between six and twelve—are where you can find consistent production, sleeper breakouts, and a few landmines. Let’s dive into the names you’ll want to target or avoid as your next dynasty quarterback.
(This is an AI-generated article from a recent Big Guy Fantasy Sports Podcast.)
More Big Guy Fantasy Football
- Mahomes Vs. Mayfield: NFL Fantasy Consistency Tiebreakers
- Most-Undervalued 2025 NFL Fantasy Football Running Backs!
- Fantasy Wide Receivers: Justin Jefferson’s that guy!
- Fantasy ADP Movers this week: Darren Waller is at the top!
Why the QB1B Tier Matters in Dynasty
Quarterback 1B refers to fantasy football quarterbacks ranked six through twelve. These are the names often available in the fifth to eighth rounds of most dynasty drafts. The elite QBs are off the board in the first few rounds, leaving this second tier to fill out the back end of QB1 rosters.
Evaluating these QBs based on consistency, supporting cast, rushing upside, and average draft position (ADP) gives an edge in building reliable dynasty teams. You’re not chasing boom-or-bust games—you want weekly stability and long-term growth. With the right pick, a QB1B can outperform his ADP and anchor your lineup.
Bo Nix: Underrated Rookie Stealing the Spotlight
Bo Nix might not be the most talked-about rookie, but his 2024 season was quietly impressive. His clutch rate was 59%, ranking ninth among fantasy football quarterbacks. Denver didn’t open the playbook until Week 5, but once they did, he averaged over 21 fantasy points per game.
Nix added 430 rushing yards, showing dual-threat potential. With over 560 pass attempts and new weapons like Evan Engram and rookie wideouts, Nix is poised for a second-year leap. James Knight ranks him as QB4 in dynasty. Don’t sleep on a quarterback who could vault into the elite tier sooner than expected.
Baker Mayfield: A Proven Starter With High-Value ADP
Baker Mayfield’s 2024 season should silence critics. He threw for 4,500 yards, scored 41 touchdowns, and finished third in total points. Even more impressive, his 82% clutch rate ranked second among fantasy football quarterbacks. Despite his production, his ADP sits around 61, making him a mid-round steal.
Mayfield has elite weapons, including Mike Evans, Chris Godwin, and first-round rookie Emeka Egbuka. Tampa Bay’s passing game is loaded, and Mayfield now thrives in a stable environment. His late breakout mirrors players who find success after bouncing around early in their careers. He’s not flashy, but he’s delivering top-tier production.
Brock Purdy: Undervalued Steady Producer in San Francisco
Brock Purdy’s quiet consistency makes him an ideal late-round dynasty quarterback. In 2024, he had a 60% clutch rate, even after missing games. He still finished 14th in total points. His current ADP is around 92, making him one of the most undervalued fantasy football quarterbacks.
Despite losing Deebo Samuel, he still has George Kittle, Christian McCaffrey, and emerging targets like Jauan Jennings and Ricky Pearsall. Purdy adds a small rushing floor, contributing 20 to 25 yards per game. He fits Kyle Shanahan’s system perfectly, giving you a reliable 20–25 points each week without needing a top-five investment.
Caleb Williams: First-Round Talent, But Is He Fantasy-Ready?
Caleb Williams posted decent rookie numbers with 3,500 yards and 20 touchdowns, but red flags remain. He was sacked 68 times and didn’t score a single rushing touchdown despite nearly 500 rushing yards. Chicago faces the second-toughest schedule in the league, which could limit his year-two breakout.
Still, he has an upgraded supporting cast including DJ Moore, Cole Kmet, and rookie Rome Odunze. Coach Ben Johnson brings credibility but isn’t sugar-coating things. Williams is being pushed hard in camp. Dynasty players should temper expectations. He’s not unplayable, but among fantasy football quarterbacks, he’s a riskier long-term bet.
Kyler Murray: Fading Rushing Floor, Fading Fantasy Appeal
Kyler Murray used to be a fantasy football quarterback with strong dual-threat value. That’s fading. Reports suggest he doesn’t want to run anymore, and he admitted he only throws where he’s told. His 53% clutch rate ranked just 11th in 2024, and his inconsistency is frustrating.
Murray’s fantasy value used to be his legs, and without them, he becomes a much less appealing option. In redraft or dynasty formats, you’re likely relying on him as a QB2 at best. Unless his mindset changes or his offense evolves, he’s not a reliable long-term solution for fantasy rosters.
Jared Goff: The Ultimate Home-Only Quarterback
Jared Goff ranks inside the top ten in total fantasy points over the last three years, but that’s misleading. His consistency rate is just 47%, and the home/road splits are brutal. At home, he averages 24 points per game with a 65% clutch rate.
On the road, that drops to 28%, which is basically unplayable. He doesn’t offer any rushing production, and five of his games in 2024 included one or fewer touchdowns. He’s fine as a QB2 or bye-week fill-in, but Goff isn’t a quarterback you want to start every week. He’s a streaming option, not a dynasty building block.
Choosing the Right QB1B for Your Dynasty Roster
Finding the right QB1B means identifying upside, avoiding inconsistency, and taking advantage of ADP values. Fantasy football quarterbacks like Bo Nix and Baker Mayfield offer both weekly production and long-term promise. Brock Purdy brings dependable points at a discount. Others, like Kyler Murray and Jared Goff, carry more risk than reward.
Caleb Williams has potential, but he must improve fast. Building a strong dynasty team starts with locking down a stable quarterback. Don’t overpay for flash. Instead, trust the consistency data and invest in the quarterbacks who are trending up without the cost of a top-five pick.
Get Your Fantasy Football Consistency Guide on Amazon!
