Consistency in Coaching is just as important as the players’ consistency. The New York Giants made big changes to their offensive staff this year. Can consistency be created in the offseason to make a difference in 2026?
Head Coach and Offensive Coordinator: By bringing in John Harbaugh, the Giants essentially brought in a whole new offense. Matt Nagy will be the Offensive Coordinator, play caller during games, and will be coaching Jaxson Dart. Greg Roman was brought in as an offensive assistant to manage the Giants run game. Unlike under Daboll, Jaxson Dart will be brought along a little more slowly. The offense will likely be run heavy unless they get behind and times running out.
Quarterback: Jaxson Dart ranked 16th in consistency last season, but his drawback is that with his reckless running, he often took unnecessary hits. He will specifically be coached by Matt Nagy this season. As OC, Nagy is likely to start with a slow, safe offensive scheme that focuses on having Dart recognize the defensive coverage and then calmly process his primary, secondary, and tertiary reads. Dart will still have his legs as a last resort, but the coaching staff has spoken openly about coaching Dart to avoid putting himself in harm’s way. Long story made short, the Giants’ preferred way to move the ball this season is going to be on the ground. Dart should finish similarly in consistency this year, hopefully with more games played.
Wide Receivers: Malik Nabers was a dream come true for owners in his rookie season, but last season that dream turned into a nightmare last season when he was injured early and didn’t return to the field. The Giants are hoping he’ll be able to start Week 1, but that hope was clouded by reports of a “second surgery” in May. As someone who had knee surgery, I think he’ll be good to go, but the Giants will handle him with kid gloves in camp and pre-season, possibly fueling fear amongst fantasy drafters. At your drafts, maybe mention the second surgery when others are listening. If you can scare them away, you can get him as a bargain in the late second, early third. Other actors in the Giants wide receiver room include Darius Slayton, Darnell Mooney, and oldie but goodie, Odell Beckham. None of those were ranked in the top 36 WR’s in consistency last season. I’m willing to gamble on Malik Nabers’ talent even if he misses the first couple games.
Running Backs: Right now, Cam Skattebo is atop the list and has been participating in off-season activities and camps. With the new Baltimore Ravens offense installed, Cam will be in the “Derrick Henry” role. They are going to use him as their No. 1 back. Last season he had 75% consistency in the eight games he played. He’s another Giants player who could slide a little in the draft. If he is fully healthy, this team will run him like the Ravens run Derrick Henry. Waiting in the wings are Tyrone Tracy and Devin Singletary, who both will contribute regularly.
Tight Ends: This is a position where the Giants really have strength this season. When Harbaugh got to New York, he very specifically requested the Giants sign Isaiah Likely. Add Likely to Theo Johnson, and opposing defenses are going to have a tough time defending these two. And who does a QB look to when he needs a quick out? This could be a situation where they both eat, or one where we won’t know from week to week which one will provide the highlights. They are likely to fall a bit in the draft because of that uncertainty. I’d grab Likely first due to his draft position, but I’d back him up with Theo Johnson.
Summary: This has the potential to be a solid offense at every position, but the Giants are going to spread the wealth. Nabers is a must-have, even with the potential for less overall passing. Jaxson Dart could be a solid second QB, but I wouldn’t spend a lot of draft capital on him. Skattebo is going to be their hammer at the goal line and in short yardage. The tight ends are going to be frustrating, like it was when Likely started stealing Mark Andrews catches in Baltimore. The offense will be brought along slowly but will get better as the season progresses.
