Catch all the Top NFL Prop Picks & Best Prop Bets right here, every week, on Big Guy Fantasy Sports!
Every week, Colby Conway and Bob Lung use the Forecaster Consistency Tool to help you win your Fantasy Football Prop Bets! Follow them @colbyconway and @bob_lung. If you are looking for some weekly NFL player props, you’ve come to the right place! There are ample player props out there, but Bob Lung and Colby Conway provide their favorite player props to target for this week’s action across the National Football League.
The consistency concept can be applied to player props, just like it has for daily fantasy sports and seasonal fantasy football, so find those consistent players to give yourself the best chance of winning some money betting on player props. Make sure to check out the Prop It Like It’s Hot podcast for even more player props for this week!
NFL Week 4 Prop Picks – 9/26/2025 – Prop It Like It’s Hot!
Week 4 NFL Prop Picks
Cam Skattebo UNDER 55.5 Rushing Yards
As much as I love this guy, it’s going to be tough going in his first game as the lead dog. The Chargers have allowed just 167 rushing yards in three games, which is right at this number per game. The Giants will have to throw quite a bit, so it’s possible he does more damage in the passing game, but this total will be tough to come by.
Nick Chubb ANYTIME TD
In a game against the Titans with an expected total of 38.5 points, there should be plenty of rushing attempts. Chubb leads the team with 34 carries, and the Titans have allowed five rushing touchdowns thus far, which is tied for the most in the league. Look for Chubb to find the end zone in a low-scoring game.
Rome Odunze OVER 5.5 Receptions
The breakout is here. Odunze has scored a TD in each game and has gone over this number in two out of three. The Raiders are near the bottom in defending the WR position, so in a game with a 47.5 total, there should be plenty of opportunities for him to hit the over.
More NFL Football Week 4
- Week 4 NFL Fantasy Football: Who’s Hot, & Who’s Not!
- Week 4: Under the Radar with Consistency
- NFL Fantasy Waiver Wire Week 4: One Week Wonders
- Fantasy Week 4 Start/Sits Advice & Football Strategy
- Fantasy Football Week 4 Studs: Consistency Kings Rising
Keon Coleman OVER 39.5 Receiving Yards
New Orleans has done well in defending the run this year, but not so much through the air. The Saints have allowed the fifth-most yards per route run and third-most fantasy points to the perimeter this season, and Coleman has a strong 2.03 yards per route run on the perimeter. He’s a big play waiting to happen, and this feels like a good spot for the second-year wideout.
Christian Kirk OVER 3.5 Receptions
L’Jarius Sneed and Nico Collins can duke it out on the outside, and that will be one to watch. However, Kirk has a far more advantageous matchup out of the slot, so that’s why we are looking here. Tennessee’s Roger McCreary has allowed the sixth-most yards per coverage snap in the slot in 2025, per Pro Football Focus. Kirk stepped right in as the WR2 and played two-thirds of the offensive snaps.
Ashton Jeanty OVER 66.5 Rushing Yards
Jeanty’s yardage has increased every week, and last week he recorded 63 yards on the ground against the Commanders. Jeanty has a porous 1.13 yards before contact per attempt, per Fantasy Points, but here’s why I like Jeanty this week. The Bears have allowed the most yards before contact per attempt (3.11), and the second-highest yards per carry overall. T.J. Edwards and Grady Jarrett both missed practice time this week, and their absence on Sunday would be huge for Jeanty’s outlook.
You can find & follow @colbyconway and @bob_lung on the X! And thank you for joining us for our Week 3 NFL Prop Picks and Best Bets!
